Kny Opinions - Tumblr Posts

Just had an argument with two classmates of mine ( boys ) who claimed that Kocho Shinobu is a burden and she deserves to die.

Safe to say that I was enraged.

Listen, I accept their opinions, they dislike Shinobu and that's ok, everyone has their own taste. But that doesn't mean I gave them the freedom to attack one of my favorite character.

Their main point of Shinobu being a burden is because she's physically weak.

Listen here you immature bastards, Shinobu is the one who helps injured slayers, gives them shelters and medicine. She is also one of the reason Douma and Muzan are dead. She's a woman who acts as the doctor and the warrior in the corps, so things aren't easy for her.

" If she's a doctor, she should just stay low and mend the injured! " - says the boys

Well she doesn't want to! She wants to fight!

" But that makes her a burden to others "

NO SHE DOES NOT.

She has the fastest breathing style, she thinks smart and works hard, don't you fucking dare says that she's a burden. Plus, it's great to have someone with medical knowledge in the battlefield.

Kocho Shinobu is a strong woman, perhaps not physically, but in other aspects, she is. So while I accept your dislike towards her, I don't appreciate you attacking her because of her flaws.

I accept your favorite character, I didn't attacked him even if I hate him, but why did you attacked mine?

Your favorite character Muzan? The one you tried to justify his actions by saying that he just wants to live? Know what the difference between him and my favorite character?

Shinobu died as a hero and Muzan died as a fucking coward.

Me, to Shinobu :

Saw a YouTube video of someone doing a 'What If Tanjirou meets another Hashira in the first episode' so here are my speculation;

Giyuu: Already in canon, Tanjirou and Nezuko are spared

Shinobu: Same as Giyuu with attacking Nezuko first but becomes immensely curious and bewildered when Nezuko protects Tanjirou. Thinks about Kanae and decides to let her curiosity wins her over. She probably make a deal with Tanjirou like "I'll recommend you a teacher for you to become a slayer in exchange for me to take your sister with me." Probably does experimenting on Nezuko because of her opposite demonic characteristics 💀 (a complicated situation, both sides trying to find the solution for a mutual agreement with Tanjirou refusing to leave Nezuko while Shinobu wants to poke her around with needles and stuff)

Kyojuro: Attacks without hesitation, stating bluntly to Tanjirou why Nezuko should be decapitated (unintentionally harsh) and does a double take when Nezuko protects Tanjirou. He might still stands on his ground but questions the whole situation. I can either see him still trying to slay Nezuko or spare her and takes Tanjirou as his student.

Mitsuri: Despite her soft and cheerful attitude, she shows little mercy when it comes to swinging her blades. She apologies first before diving into an attack. Very shock at seeing how Nezuko protects Tanjirou and starts complicating on what she should do next, to continue her mission or spare the siblings. She might needs to sit down and thinks for a moment. The outcome probably with her sparing them.

Muichiro: So honest with his words, insults Tanjirou at hoping for Nezuko to be good. Attacks but pauses when Nezuko is protecting Tanjirou. Maybe tilts his head and stares, asking Nezuko if she has ulterior motives. The most possible outcome of this situation is him to continue his mission and slays Nezuko, reminding himself that his responsibility as a slayer outweigh everything else.

Uzui: Doesn't filter his words when it comes to explaining to Tanjirou on why the boy is stupid enough to protect his demon sister. His eyes get wide when Nezuko protects Tanjirou and questions swimming around his mind. Either he decides to grasp onto the tiny possiblity that Nezuko can be good, or that he goes ahead to behead her. I see Uzui as a hopeful man clinging on to exciting possiblity of impossible situations, so he might takes Tanjirou as his student but keeps Nezuko lock or isolated away 💀

Gyomei: He thinks the situation is pitiful and hopeless, that Tanjirou is in too much despair to hope his sister still has the humanity in her. Even with blind eyes, Gyomei senses the change of the atmosphere when Nezuko stands over Tanjirou like a protection barrier between him and Tanjirou. He keeps wondering how such thing is possible, how a child like Nezuko decides to risk her life for her human brother that she probably never has memory of. He thinks of the chance that maybe she's being defensive over her food. Either he goes for a killing strike, or to have Tanjirou learning under his guidance while keeping close watch on Nezuko.

Obanai: Very harsh insults, thinks Nezuko has ulterior motive for protecting Tanjirou and beheads her 💀

Sanemi: We all know where this is going 💀 Kill first ask later.